« The writing's on the wall | Main | Free online at BJP »

Police v Photographers. Don't take stop-and-search lying down

Have you been the victim of the UK police's misuse of stop-and-search powers (many photographers have been stopped in their usual line of duty, reporting news, or even just shooting a wedding, despite reassurances that this will stop), and if so, what did you do about it?

Perhaps you didn't know you could do anything, but in an entertaining piece in The Guardian this week, comedian and activist Mark Thomas details how he managed to prove his own experience of stop-and-seach was unlawful.

Thomas was stopped in September 2007 outside an arms fair in the Docklands in London after he attempted to walk past the police with an "over-confident manner". No kidding.



He writes:

"Although protesters are often targeted for stop and search, often claiming these are unlawful, they seldom seem to put in official complaints. So with the help of solicitors at Fisher Meredith I brought a complaint against the police. Being Britain the first step in a complaint against an official body is for the very body you are complaining about to investigate itself. And lo the police did find themselves innocent."


But he wouldn't let it lie – despite the police officers who conducted the stop and search expressing "surprise and disapointment" that he complained having found Thomas "pleasant and conversational throughout the incident". I'm really not making this up.

So he took his compaint to the Independent Police Complaints Commission, and to his own surprise, it delivered a verdict that the stop and search was illegal, stating that "it would appear that the officers had misinterpreted their powers under Police And Criminal Evidence Act (PACE)".



Thomas concludes:

"It is in the cases where they get it wrong that attitudes towards police are sharpened and the rights we feel we have as citizens practically defined. So I am writing to the police requesting a formal admission of liability on the part of the commissioner and damages for assault and false imprisonment".


So the next time you're stopped by police (under the PACE act or counter-terrorism powers) and you think you've been unfairly targeted, make sure you follow up and make a complaint. The following investigation will take up valuable police time, but that might discourage officers from taking up too much of your valuable time in the future.

Mark Thomas is speaking at The Convention on Modern Liberty later this month, alongside Brian Eno, Shami Chakrabarti of Liberty and Chris Huhne MP – plus dozens of others at events in London, Belfast, Bristol, Cambridge, Cardiff, Glasgow and Manchester.

The Convention offers "a call to all concerned with attacks on our fundamental rights and freedoms under pressure from counter-terrorism, financial breakdown and the database state".

Comments (1)

Brian Jones:

Interesting.

I carry dual nationality and was in Central London - just outside St Paul's cathedral - in Sept 2008. I was taking innocent shots with a 200mm lens (the usual touristy stuff) when all of a sudden, two of London's finest approach me, ask me if I'm a journo (I'm not but I do have pro quality gear) and then proceed to give me the gears: what am I doing, can they see my camera, can they see my ID etc.

My UK accent made them feel pretty confident but as soon as I produced my Canadian passport things changed and it was "oh oh, sorry to have bothered you; have a nice day". Obviously the thought of engaging a foreign national and the limitless paperwork that might ensue was enough to deter them and leave me alone.

After that, I walked around for a few hours deliberatly shooting all the CCTV cameras I could see to show my Canadian friends just what a police state the UK is turning into.

Next time - and I'm sure there will be one - I'm gonna decline to help and lodge a formal complaint.

Roll on 2012!!

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

About

BJP Cover

 

1854 brings you a daily dose of photographic news, from the latest gear to the best exhibitions to the best insights on ongoing and upcoming trends in the industry. 1854 is written by the editors of the British Journal of Photography, the world's oldest photography magazine


Twitter Updates


    This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License

    Powered by

    Movable Type 3.36

    © The British Journal of Photography

    Google Ads

    Resources


    © The British Journal of Photography